Press "Enter" to skip to content

A skill to master critical thinking | Syed Samir Anis | TEDxMuscatSalon


oh right it for that I was supposed to

read this before coming read it right

now okay I guess I’ll read it although

so place yourself in front of the ball

straighten your non-dominant leg

contract the hamstrings of your dominant

leg make a 45-degree angle about your

knee contract your quadriceps to extend

your leg and make contact with the ball

what did I just read it’s better to show

you that’s it I just read the

instructions on how to kick a ball now

these students are very clear

it’s literally giving you the muscle

physiology of how to make contact with

the ball and then watch the flight is

that necessary no I mean you know how to

kick a ball you’ve been kicking a ball

to see where you were a child right it’s

one of the first things we actually

learn how to do now imagine a

hypothetical situation where there’s an

individual who’s never interacted with

the ball you grew up in a village

somewhere never knew what a ball is

never saw it and you place the ball in

front of but for some reason remember

this hypothetical they have perfect

proficiency in English and when they

read the instructions you think they’ll

be able to kick the ball probably not

they’re gonna try they’re gonna fail and

remember that word fail then ever try

again fail again try again fail again

until eventually they get it now was

that because of the instructions it was

because they kept on trying and they

kept on failing right now was it

necessary for the instructions like I

asked before no so I don’t need these

instructions I know how to kick a ball I

reassured you will do it again right now

try that again

[Music]

wait this balls a little deflated okay I

thought both balls would be the same

that’s what I asked for but this one is

deflated that doesn’t help me at all the

instructions had absolutely no advice on

how to deal with a deflated ball they

told me how to deal with the optimal

situation which is a

perfectly inflated ball also assuming I

have perfectly functioning legs now now

I failed at kicking this ball as well as

the first one because again

hypothetically I’ve never dealt with a

deflated ball before and the

instructions didn’t advise me on how to

deal with it but I try it again I know

this time that the ball is deflated I

need more power but from my previous

experience I’m going to sacrifice

accuracy because of that power so I’m

gonna increase my accuracy by taking my

shoe off applying more power I’m kicking

it perfectly now of course this is a

very basic example I know how to kick a

ball so don’t judge my motor skills

please and the second ball was supposed

to be deflated so don’t judge the ohms

the organization team because this is

supposed to happen no my point being I

had to fail because if I hadn’t failed I

wouldn’t have learned it for some reason

in our society not just our society

everywhere you go to west or the east

failure is such a stigma nobody wants

their child to fail the math test even

though it’s just a six-year-old child

and what’s worse is you compete with

everyone else how come you got a 97 when

your cousin got a 99 on the exact same

example what’s worse is how come you got

a 60 when your cousin got a 98 in the

exact same exam why are you punishing

the child for failing he’s a child he’s

supposed to fail at this point you’re

supposed to tell him try to figure out

what you did wrong so then next time you

have the same problem you don’t do it

again you learn from your mistakes you

learn how to solve the problem you learn

how to think and thinking critical

situations and that’s the whole point

top right now hydro problem solve and

think critically so why do you think

you’re bad at thinking critically

because you haven’t done it myself

included and I came up with this

realization fairly young I was very

lucky when I was

about 14 years old I was a overweight

short grade 9 kid who really wanted to

play basketball really wanted to play

basket because all of his friends played

basketball they were all good it’s just

the sidelines because bubble with them I

also had ads whoa didn’t help so what I

did was I downloaded and printed

instructions on how to shoot a

basketball that was my only chance I

couldn’t run and keep up with him I had

to shoot so I download these

instructions which was the inspiration

of the football example here and I

started reading these instructions at

the school gymnasium after classes and

while I was reading I was so intent on

memorizing every single step and I

believe that memorizing these

instructions would lead me to shoot a

basketball properly because that’s what

I do in classes I study then I’m gonna

write the exams the exams are the exact

questions that I study and is perfectly

fine no problem so let’s try that here

while I was doing that my physic teacher

snuck up behind me and I don’t know if

you guys are aware of the stereotypes in

teachers in the West they’re very harsh

and especially the guys they believe in

tough love so when I was reading this he

saw me and literally just started

laughing at me he was actually mocking

me you think it doesn’t matter if you

memorize every single word in this

document if you remember every single

word on how to shoot a ball and every

book written and every single word on

the internet on how to shoot a

basketball you’ll never be able to shoot

a basketball until you actually shoot a

basketball so he made me shoot the

basketball 50 times that day and I’m

serious I’m not making this up I missed

every single shot because I just didn’t

have the strength by the time I got to

the 20 shot my arms felt like jelly but

he made me finish anyway he made me do

that several times that week I must have

missed almost a thousand shots I’m not

exaggerating 50 shots a date for a few

weeks I’m gonna miss most of those shots

but eventually I got my first shot now

why did I get that first shot and a lot

of people think it’s because you

experienced you tried so many times

eventually you figured out how to do it

it wasn’t so much that I figured out

what to do it was more of a process of

elimination I kept on failing and every

time I missed a shot I realized what I

did wrong and I

justified sometimes I had too much power

sometimes I sacrificed accuracy

sometimes actual sacrifice power for

accuracy wise vice-versa a lot of

factors and it took me hundreds of shots

to figure out the optimal ratio to get

the ball into the net right so that’s my

point here you have to fail you should

fail failing is good isn’t it better

that you fail when you’re young and

you’re not liable and you won’t be held

accountable then when you fail when you

are older and you are liable and it’ll

held accountable fail now learn from

now pretty much explain to you guys why

you guys suck including myself at

problem-solving critical thinking what’s

the solution there are many solutions

and there are many different pathways

everyone can take the whole point is you

have to try you have to put yourself

into situations where you have to solve

problems because the issue is ever since

you started school you’ve been sheltered

you’ve been given ideal situations you

go and your memorize your perfect

inflated ball scenario go to your exam

hall answer the perfect scenario with

your perfect answer and then you go home

and then when you get to real life

you’re deflated ball comes and you don’t

know what to do so experience your

deflated ball before you get to real

life before you graduate and the best

way to do that the first step what I did

which may some of you may have already

done it to observe people who have

already failed countless times the

experience people they’re all around you

most of them sitting in the front first

few ropes you know that the thing about

experienced individuals is that they

want they always want to share their

experience so leech off of that

experience see what they do differently

see observe when they are they approach

a problem the way they approach a

problem how they come up with a solution

and how they succeed at solving that

problem there right there you won’t be

able to emulate it perfectly because

you’re just starting out but now you’ll

so once you have that basis you can move

forward and it does it doesn’t have to

be within your college it can be

anywhere now if you’re a medical student

go to the clinics more go to the

hospital more interact with patients

more learn from the patient learn their

side of the perspective look at the

doctors at how they are treating the

patients how they’re taking history how

they’re approaching the problem look at

your seniors even look at the students

that are younger than you you always

learn from other people observe how

they’re solving problems try it if it

works for you great if it doesn’t try

something else try to come up with

something yourself now let’s say it’s

too hard you’re not able to make it to

the hospital so much you’re not able to

observe people that solve problems on a

daily basis you still have people in

your family that do that every day you

have your parents specifically your

mother you’d be amazed at how many times

your mother solves serious issues every

day like it’s nothing it’s mind-boggling

because I remember when I was about I

was very young about 9 or 10 years old

and I was making a project from my

school and I was there was a lot of

electrical work along and I had one of

the extension wires that you see over

here an outlet my little brother somehow

he was riding his bike the wire was very

thin in a cut in half and I had no time

I had to go to school right away so what

do I do as most kids do they run to

their mother say what am I supposed to

do I’m gonna fail this is not gonna work

so she goes into the air to blow my

father’s toolbox takes out these pliers

rips the wire apart takes the copper

wiring tape him together with electrical

I was like this there this will work and

I’m like great she’s all another problem

or I went to school did the project I

did fairly well and came back and then a

few years later after that I came up

with a similar situation I’m like oh I

know what to do now I did the same thing

it worked relatively well not as well as

when she did it but it did and that’s

when I realized

how does she know how to do that she’s

not an electrical engineer right she

studied journalism how does she know how

to do this it’s because she’s

experienced these situations so many

times in her life not just for herself

but for her entire family for years

that’s something like this just didn’t

even faze her so why not leach off of

that experience it’s right there give

yourself the headstart the second thing

you could do which I mentioned before to

be better at problem solving and

critical thinking is to place yourself

in situations where you will have

problems daunting unimaginable problems

something that you really expect to fail

in because like I said failing is good

don’t be afraid to fail embrace it so

the ideal situation is one long task

that takes a what to perform you have

your final goal and you’re starting off

with nothing and you know there will be

a lot of different problems in between

I’ll give you an example of that of what

yes so you can see in this picture over

here we built a maze it’s a human-sized

maze right you can actually go into the

maze and you come out in one of the four

entrances anywhere else.this okay it’s

amazing but do you realize how amazing

this is for a few here for students to

pull off on their own they have limited

resources limited finances they have no

experience in construction whatsoever

and they have very little time this was

during human function all right but they

still succeeded and being part of that

team I can tell you we had no idea what

we’re doing we had no idea how we were

gonna succeed we thought we were gonna

fail but that didn’t stop us few

creative individuals and our team just

came up with a concept of using a

human-sized maze we just wanted to do

that we don’t know how it was relevant

to the event we didn’t know what the

point of it was we don’t know what we

were gonna do with it we didn’t know how

to make it and we didn’t even know what

materials we needed we didn’t even know

where we were gonna make it it was

really convenient we had a wide open

courtyard last year so we had about five

or six problems in front of us

but we took them at a time what’s the

first step find out what we’re gonna do

with the maze so we sat down and we came

up with a game how do we use it maze

okay we came up with really awesome

scenarios of something like the zombie

apocalypse

it was a really fun day I don’t have

time to go into detail about the game

itself but you can talk to me afterwards

I can tell you so once we came up with a

solution of what to do with the maze how

do we build the maze then we were going

so we were trying to come up with

solutions how to build a maze one of the

members in our team said that she knows

an architect her sister actually so she

sat down with her and gave her the

guidelines of what we needed and they

designed the maze together then we had

an outline of the maze the next step

build the maze so while we had members

trying to get permission to actually use

this area we just started working anyway

because

if we didn’t get the permission whatever

we’ll just start somewhere else again

from the beginning why waste time so we

started making based on the measurements

we started making out the layouts

this is us working in night at night so

you can see us measuring out the layout

of the maze and keep in mind at this

time we still have no idea how we’re

gonna build the maze but we solved our

first problem which was what we’re gonna

do with the maze now you see the chalk

over there that we’re using the maze was

huge it ran out with about a quarter

over well the only 1/4 of the maze was

mapped out three-quarters of the mazes

left what are we gonna do quickly we’re

thinking okay someone go buy spray paint

we’ll just use them right hopefully um

Simo but it’s sad we’ll just move it

over and hide it later so another

solution we have um our outline

perfectly well done still don’t know how

to build a maze all right then we come

back the next day all happy that we did

so much work and we see it in the

sunlight from the top the measurements

are completely off can I tell you we

have no experience we didn’t know how to

measure these properly this time we use

measuring tape and we did it properly

this time and we got more chalk more

space spray paint so we already then the

next day when we saw it in the morning

hoping it worked better this time it

worked very well and what we were doing

that we still needed a way to build a

may so we’re trying many different

things while we were still measuring we

were looking for solutions for problems

we knew we were gonna face later on

while we were working on a current

problem as well so we tried many things

we try to actually dig and put wooden

pillars in didn’t work I tried metal

beams didn’t work eventually and this is

a golden rule for problem solving look

at your surroundings what resources do

you have available to you we said OMC is

under heavy construction right now

they’re really rushing to get a lot of

work done

we need help with construction why don’t

we ask for advice from

construction workers we went to them we

told them we need this this and this how

do you suggest we go along with it they

gave us a lot of steps and scenarios and

we were able to move along and get these

pillars up once these pillars were up we

realized that yeah these are this is

hollow

there’s nothing here people just go

right through well you know what just

cover it with cloth we’ll have to do

with manual boiler just cover it with

cloth we covered it with cloth and then

when there with the final product that I

showed you before and the game went

phenomenal and I can go into more detail

with inmates because the problems didn’t

end until the last possible minute

actually until the game ended even after

when we didn’t know how to dispose of it

but the problems kept on coming and we

kept on solving the problems as they

came that’s the point there’s always a

solution if you didn’t find the

solutions because you didn’t find the

solution but that doesn’t matter if we

had fit that this oh whatever it looks

bad but we would have learned a lot

which we did anyway and use it the next

time I’m telling you all the people that

work in this project most of them are

involved in TEDx and TEDx was easy

compared to that because we went through

this already we came straight to FedEx

it wouldn’t be as this successful right

so the final message is take-home

messages bail fail now so you don’t fail

later okay

face the variable if love life of the

deflated ball right now so when you see

it the next time you can kick the deflated ball right in the face

Please follow and like us: