Press "Enter" to skip to content

Traumatic Connection: Women and Health Care Providers | Elizabeth Shadigian | TEDxJHUDC


thank you for your patience mm-hmm

when was the last time a health care

provider asked if you had been

gang-raped when is the last time a

health care provider asks if your

partner chokes you when is the last time

a health care provider asked if you had

been treated hurtfully as a child or

neglected in some way when is the last

time a doctor or dentist asked if they

my name is Elizabeth I’m a 52 year-old

privileged white straight sis woman

mother daughter sister friend partner

when I was a medical student and in my

ob/gyn residency several times I was

solicited by senior physicians to have

sex with them one of them even

threatened to have me kicked out of my

residency program if I said anything to

anyone

I had an 80 year-old esteemed Dinah

ecology professor pinched my butt

I had a surgeon in the operating room of

a major teaching hospital throw

instruments so close to my eye I was

welcome to the best medical school in

the world I was just a woman I was just

another woman

when I was a medical student when I was

a resident when I was a professor I

always felt like I wasn’t doing a good

enough job that I could have done a

better job if I had just had a little

bit more time and knew a little bit more

about the person in front of me and then

I could do an amazing job for them one

thing that propelled me into this field

of course were there things that I

experienced both as a child as a

teenager as an undergraduate as a

medical student as an OBGYN resident and

even the things that happened to me when

I was a professor I knew I wanted to be

asked to be touched before I was touched

I knew that it felt more respectful

because when we’re not asked and someone

just does something to us even if it’s

in a medical situation it feels like

another trauma another abuse and

especially for those people especially

women who’ve been hurt before

it’s a pile-on of that feeling of

disrespect over and over again the

current health care model which I call

status quo health care is based on

paternalism daddy’s right the doctors

right the more senior doctor is more

right this paternalism pervades society

and we don’t really think about it in

health care but it’s there ask any woman

who’s been cut off when she’s tried to

ask questions who’s been made fun of for

being a Google ologist by researching

actual questions and topics before an

appointment this system which I call

status quo health care does not have to

be the model of health care it’s not

medicine itself that the problem is

medicine actually is amazing we’re going

forward in medicine we’re learning new

things we’re learning more about people

we’re learning more about nanoparticle

we’re learning more about how to treat

people with respect I created a new kind

of model of healthcare and I call it

woman safe health with safety in between

woman and health it however applies to

everyone women just happen to be on the

lower end of power in society but it

applies to everyone

women girls trans and gender

when I was a professor I came in one day

at a major teaching institution to take

care of Sonia Sonia was in her 30s it

wasn’t her first child she’d had all

vaginal deliveries I came in with my

three kids at home to spend time with

her and to help her with her birth on my

way out the door

a more senior physician on faculty said

to me you shouldn’t come in for

deliveries on days you’re not really on

call because you’re making the rest of

us look bad you never asked me why why

did I come in on my day off

to take care of a woman who’d had plenty

of normal births before he didn’t ask me

because he didn’t want to know he was

on other occasions I’ve been the patient

that’s the interesting thing we have to

look at things from both sides I’m not

just the physician I’m the patient I’m

also a woman advocate a woman advocate

is someone who supports other women

really other people obtaining medical

care and why is that important

because when we come to medical care

we’re in a vulnerable position we feel

like we have less power because actually

we do we’re relying on somebody else to

tell us what’s wrong with us and we come

with fear we come with nervousness we

come with sometimes dread because we’re

not sure if we’re going to be believed

we don’t know if we’re going to be

woman safe health is a model that

focuses on welcoming welcoming people to

medical care it focuses on listening to

the concerns of the client notice I said

the client not the patient a client is

the term we use for patient under woman

safe health a client is someone who

seeks a consultant someone in a

non-hierarchical relationship and who

wants not to be talked down to but be

looked at across the aisle in the eyes

and respected a patient is a person

receiving health care a client is

someone who has more power and even if

they don’t know what their diagnosis is

wants to be treated with respect another

part of women’s safe health is belief

believing the person in front of us we

don’t have to believe that every piece

of minutia they’re telling us is

factually correct what we’re doing is

believing their paradigm of living

believing how they

experience their symptoms how they are

in families this paradigms very

important to understand because many

people look down especially physicians

look down upon clients who can’t give an

accurate history or history as I like to

say the other thing we all want in

health care is to have our know

respected we don’t want to just do what

the doctor says

we have brain cells to even when we’re

in the client role and we may not want a

medication because maybe our mother was

allergic to that medication or maybe I

don’t want to go to that hospital

because that’s where my grandmother died

or on and on there are a whole bunch of

reasons why when we’re in the client

role we may want or not want something

and so I will propose to you that the

model of care must include a respect of

no in society this is exactly what sets

up violence is that the perpetrator does

not respect the victim they don’t

respect know it’s all about the

perpetrator and their goals and what

they want at the time when I was a

client at a status quo health care

institution one that I actually taught

at I went in and I brought my husband

with me we sat patiently waiting for the

doctor and when she arrived she stood up

put her papers on a podium it was really

a supply cabinet with lots of other

things inside and proceeded to ask

questions I interrupted her I said this

prefer to stand I’m asking you kindly

could you please sit down it really kind

of bothers me that you’re standing up

and I’m sitting down how long have you

had fire road problems I stood up I

walked to the hurt supply cabinet I put

my elbow on it just like she was and

said 21 years why are you being so

combative I preferred if you sat down

but you didn’t so I decided to stand up

how’s that combative when we’re faced

with these situations which come out of

the blue during a medical appointment

none of us expect to go into a medical

appointment and necessarily be

disrespected instead we go no thinking

we’re going to be treated well thinking

that the doctor will listen to us and

believe what we’re saying but when we

have an encounter we always have to have

our guard up it’s difficult to just

relax at a medical appointment all of us

go in thinking okay how many minutes do

I have with the doctor am I going to

have enough time to get through the

three things that I really need to talk

about today probably not because maybe

it’s only been designated for you to

have five minutes maybe only one topic

are you allowed to discuss so when we go

into a medical appointment we need to be

armed with more information and really

it’s not information but analysis so

when we think about doctor surgeon who I

saw in myself is the patient or the

client we need to do a care analysis

which is a power analysis of the

situation

was power being held over me as a

patient versus handed to me and she knew

I was a physician

maybe I got treated worse because of

that I don’t know so when I look back on

what happened I think of four things the

doctor surgeon did to me first she

ignored my woman advocate a woman

advocate again is someone who supports

women really anyone going to medical

appointments so she very consciously

ignored the people in the room – she

decided to stand up with no discussion

about how that might affect me it

probably didn’t even cross her mind it

might affect me three when I asked her

to sit down she chose not to she

completely ignored my request she could

have actually asked why or said well you

know I’m really sorry but I have a back

injury and I can’t sit down but she

decided to ignore me in my request and

for she then labeled me as combative for

asking for what I wanted and to to try

to be equalizing the power between us by

standing up when these things happen and

we really have the opportunity to step

back and look at how power is being

shared or not when we’re in that client

role we have some choices and those

choices are called empowerment acts

empowerment acts are any kind of

behaviors thought processes or actions

we might take the increase our power or

respect for ourselves during an

encounter and we’re talking about

medical encounters today but it can be

in our life in other ways so there were

six things that I did is that client is

that patient that day that were

empowerment acts the first thing which

I’m going to encourage everyone to do is

to bring an advocate a woman advocate

with you a woman advocate will increase

your power just by having another person

in the room someone to witness

the respect or disrespect that you may

experience the second empowerment act is

I didn’t let her not acknowledge my

woman advocate I introduced him he still

didn’t acknowledge him

the third empowerment act was to ask for

what I wanted not just to put up with

poor treatment so I asked her to sit

down I didn’t get what I asked but at

least I asked and that made me feel good

about me

and what I needed the fifth thing was

that I actually stood up I took another

action and looked her in the eye I

didn’t hide my eyes I looked directly at

her and I think that was something she

didn’t expect that’s for sure and

finally I did not agree with what she

called me which was combative that was

not a question that was an oppressive

statement used to silence me so when

we’re in a situation in medical care we

have some options maybe you have never

thought about how you’ve been treated

but my guess is everyone has been

treated poorly sometimes and that’s how

abuse works that’s how oppression works

by alternating in the medical setting

professionalism and this thinly

disguised veil of disrespect and

oppression what I call traumatic

that’s how abuse works and that’s how

status quo healthcare works because

we’re hooked we have to get kind of care

somewhere and we’re willing to put up

with disrespect to get a crumb of care

because we’re afraid because we’re

worried because we can’t write a

prescription because we don’t know

what’s going on with us we don’t have to

tolerate this anymore there are other

ways to receive health

to be empowered through health care and

there’s two parts of this one is us

coming as clients or patients to health

care and analyzing the power dynamics

analyzing the empowerment acts I can do

I could have walked out of the

appointment with doctor surgeon I could

have just walked out and said goodbye

and we can do that that’s another

empowerment act unfortunately where else

are we going to go so we put up with

things on the other hand health care

providers physicians nurses etc can

change the way they’re practicing they

can slow down they can really listen

they can believe and they can treat

others with the respect that they would

want to have when they are patients

themselves so I want you to think about

it very carefully what do we have to do

to change the model of healthcare not

just in this room but around the world

and have empowerment respect an

anti-oppression be at the heart of healthcare

Please follow and like us: