Press "Enter" to skip to content

Dare to Be an Economist | Raša Karapandža | TEDxEBS


I was 15 2014 I was on a train from

Frankfurt to Berlin and I met a super

interesting person we had a fantastic

conversation and we talked about

everything about books about physics

about lots of different things and after

some time after 2 hours approximately

this person asked me what do you do and

I told him I’m an economist and his

first reaction was but why you see smart

why aren’t you something useful like an

engineer or something like that and then

I told him no no but I’m also

astrophysicist because I graduated

astrophysics before getting into grad

school for economics and I felt really

bad after after that conversation I

basically I did not what I you know I

was astrophysicists but why would I have

to justify myself for spending 6 years

in grad school doing lots of work

learning about lots of different

scientific methods doing lots of

freezers doing lots of teaching and then

at the end I have to just justify to a

person on a train for being an economist

a fee feeling bad after that when I told

him so now I think that in Germany when

you mention an economist people start

getting some impressions and in the u.s.

these impressions are quite different

and German public probably doesn’t even

know who are these people even though

their Nobel prize-winning economists and

I believe there are many reasons why

Germany has a very different than

particular view on the

Animists compared to for example us when

you say that you are an economist people

think okay

this guy is kind of smart that’s

basically the same thing this physicists

do but receives a paycheck which is

double in size so they think you are

kind of even cooler than a physicist but

in Germany when you say that you are an

economist the perception is very very

different in a sense I was pretty

ashamed of being an economist in Germany

I believe that we can even by using an

economic theory we can explain why is

this to some extent at least one of the

reasons I believe is hidden behind an

economic theory which won a Nobel Prize

to George Akerlof which is about the

adverse selection if an audience is not

aware who are lamins who are peaches you

will tend to offer an average price and

then if you offer an average price you

will end up by only laments actually

accepting this price because peaches you

know their Nobel prize-winning economist

is difficult to get him to speak on TV

in Germany they’re expensive so at the

end these lemons drive out peaches out

of the market and this is what is called

the adverse selection now but this goes

really far German society let’s go back

to August 22nd 2014 Nobel in the

meetings

German Chancellor speaking in front of

the eleven nobel prize-winning

economists and more than 400 economists

from all around the planet and giving a

statement that she doesn’t believe to

economists without getting into too much

details but i believe that one of the

reasons is that she doesn’t distinguish

between lemons and peaches now the goal

of this lecture is actually I will talk

about three completely different stories

so this is an omnibus of three different

stories and in these three different

stories I will actually try to tell you

what economics is about and actually

that is about the economic methods that

people are using and that it’s actually

a real hard science

and that by using and developing these

complicated scientific stools economies

tend to sometimes at least ask very

interesting questions so I will first

start talking about promises what’s the

best way to start talking about promises

then by making some promises so I will

promise some things I will tell you how

to eat insects I will tell you how to

see true nuances I will tell you how to

leverage your talent I will show you how

to foster compassion and I will show you

the face of God and then I will ask you

don’t do believe me well note one thing

there’s one interesting phenomena that

they actually show them the previous

slides and this is the tip all these

sentences I used future tense in order

to promise to make a promise which makes

it easy actually to analyze in a text so

by using one of the fastest

supercomputers in the world at that time

that was in back in 2006 this is a Mayan

awesome this is a 10000 processor

computer when it was built it was the

fastest computer in the world

supercomputer in the world currently is

probably in the top 300 or 500 but it’s

probably still the most beautiful one

it’s actually located in one Church in

Barcelona and has a cooling coming from

a swimming pool which looks like it was

built in Roman times now what did I do

well I wanted to check that there is a

relationship between the number of

promises that people make and the

subsequent performance so I basically

took all annual reports of full American

components we are talking about millions

and millions of annual reports that

companies filled with the Securities and

Exchange Commission and I wanted to see

whether companies that promise more do

worse or better than those that promise

less and it turns out if you start with

100 dollars and invest in two companies

that promise the least compared to those

that promise the most you will end up

with profits which are almost three

times larger than what you would expect

but you know economic method or finance

method does not stop there

economists know about experiments as

well so what I did is I did an

experiment I selected a group of

students and to these students I wanted

to sell vacations in Caribbeans so

basically took the advertisements of

travel agencies about two different

vacation packages and Caribbeans

and to the control group I gave them the

advertisement that look kind of similar

and turned out the students prefer

slightly the ad of agency be compared to

agency a so more students would opt for

a vacation of agency B then in a three

days group what I did is I changed the

ad of ABC B so that every statement that

was made in a past tense was translated

into future terms like a promise so

instead of saying our customers have

enjoyed beautiful beaches I change it to

our customers will enjoy beautiful

beaches and what we observe is that

students suddenly start disliking

at least large portion of them start

disliking the advertisement which is

making explicit promises and what was

going to happen in the future but you

know promises are a phenomena that is

not new promises exists basically since

ever and there is even a book about the

promises in Shakespeare’s works and I

think it’s actually a good moment to

talk about one shaksperean character as

Brian Trenton the lead character of

Breaking Bad’s recently said we have

lots of experienced characters in

and they tend to talk a lot about the

future they tend to talk make many

promises like I will make everything

great everything will be great

everything will be perfect I will build

a great wall everything will be perfect

America will be great again so can we

say something about the outcome of the

u.s. presidential elections then look by

looking into promises that American

presidential candidates make it turns

out that in every basically almost every

only one with only one exception

candidate make fewer promises one

majority of votes so less you promise

better you do on the American elections

now you can ask me so if this is a

science can you make some prediction so

who’s gonna win the presidential

elections next week well you know this

is a difficult question but you know

econometrics which is which is part of

economic science can help us why what’s

the problem well the problem is there

are many different things that are

influencing the outcome of presidential

elections like how did the economy do

last year or some people claim that – or

presidential candidate and the one with

more here will win the elections

obviously I would never win the election

in this case but we can disentangle all

these effects using statistical tools

developed in econometrics and it turns

out that actually I can’t give you a

prediction and it turns out that my

prediction is that Trump will lose the

elections because he’s promising a lot

more than Hillary does because I feel

make everything great again everything

right so what’s the message of this

lecture well it depends who are you

talking to

first message would be there are two

groups of people those that notice that

people that promise a lot do worse and

those that do not

well those

that do not notice actually can learn

something from this lecture and start

doubting when they see when people talk

a lot and move promises about the future

second is you know advertising agencies

or any company that wants to talk about

the future well they should think twice

before making lots of promises now I

move to Story number two I told you I

will show you the face of God but before

I do that I will show you one social

network this is a social network of

characters in the book on a kyrenia so

curt two characters are connected if

they know each other in a book and the

larger the circle is the more connection

it has done actually on this movie you

can see a circle denoted Anna Karenina

which is kind of the large circle in the

network now today when you mention

social network people usually think of

Facebook people usually think of Twitter

and these kind of social networks but

social network Shipman studied in

Economic Sciences

long time ago before Facebook existed

then I encountered one study in this

study a group of mathematicians

reconstructed the network of who knows

who in Moreau comics Superman spider-man

in these kind of characters and that

mathematicians and mathematicians wanted

to say something about this network and

they said there is a statistical

property which is called clustering

coefficient which is actually very easy

concept it is a probability that the

friend of my friend is my friend too in

other words if Batman and Superman are

friends and spider-man is Superman’s

friends what is the probability that he

is also Batman’s friend in real social

networks this probability is around 30%

well it turns out that in Marvel Comics

this probability is very far off what we

observe in real life

and these mathematicians conclude that

by looking at clustering coefficient we

can distinguish fiction from the reality

when I read this research paper my

obvious thought was who cares you know

we know that Marvel Comics the Marvel

Comics is a fiction so I wanted to ask a

question where we are not actually sure

what’s the truth so what I did is I

started looking at the Bible so I wanted

to reconstruct a network of characters

in the Bible and to study the structure

of the network in the Bible so this is

one page taken from one Bible and you

can see that some names were mentioned

we have powerful enough computers that

you can actually detect the names in the

text and we can we can somehow establish

relationships between different

characters in the Bible so what you can

see here is that for example one measure

of who knows who could be two characters

know each other if they are in the same

verse if one does that one gets a

network of the Bible I promise to show

you the face of God and you can actually

see God on this network you can see also

Jacob you can see Satan you can see

Jesus you can see all characters that

appear in the Bible in this network well

there are many results that pop out of

this research of mine first interesting

result is for example how do you define

a relationship how do you define who is

connected to whom well you can say two

characters are connected if they are in

the same words but you can also say two

characters are connected if they are in

the same chapter this kind of they don’t

really know each other but they have met

somewhere if you introduce this kind of

connections it turns out that the most

popular character in the Bible is singer

of King Solomon I call him a Michael

Jackson of a Bible he kind of he was in

big concerts and stuff and he knows lots

of people but he knows the only

superficially but then in essence he is

lonely because if you define a

relationship more closely he’s basically

very very unconnected like that now you

cannot ask me so is there a god well

this is out of domain of this research I

don’t try to answer whether there is a

God or there is no God but you can ask

me whether this network looks like real

social networks that we can observe

today or we could have had observed in

history well I can

this probability is very low this

network looks very unlike real social

networks probability that the friend of

my friend is my friend too in the Bible

is for example 98 percent there are

simply too many artifacts in the Bible

there’s too many 7 kings and no 6 kings

there are too many three brothers and

there are simply no 2 or 4 brothers the

network looks in a bit a bit different

than real society – I don’t know move to

the third storey I will talk to you

about the game of hide-and-seek

he’s a kid I hated the game of

hide-and-seek I couldn’t stand it even

though this is the most popular game

that kids play all around our planet it

is played in every country in the world

it is by far the most popular game that

kids play on our planet but there’s a

kid I hated it I couldn’t play it and

the reason why I could not play it it’s

simple there were basically two set of

rules the next person that is going to

see can search for other kids is going

to be the first one that is discovered

or in an alternative set of rules it

would be the last one that was

discovered that is going to be the next

seek now I had a problem with that as a

kid and my problem was that first in the

first version after the first person is

discovered you know he’s the next seeker

why would you continue playing this game

this is like imagine you play football

you play 19 minutes and the rules are

such that the one that scores the first

Vince but you still continue playing 90

minutes it simply makes no sense in the

second set of rules you’re punishing the

best hidden one so you’re basically the

last one that is discovered is going to

be the next seeker so you are punishing

the person with his key to hit himself

the best it made no sense to me and this

is a kid I hated this game I never

wanted to play it you know other kids

were playing I said no I don’t play this

game

it makes no sense so in my grad school

when I did my PhD in economics I learned

about the game theory and the game

theory is a field of microeconomics in

which basically almost any human

interaction can be represented as a game

and the game of seek is one of them so I

decided to use the tools of

microeconomics and the game theory to

modify this game to make it have sense

to make it reasonable so what did I do

well I needed to fix some problems there

was a problem of uncertainty and there

was problem of injustice so how do they

do solve these problems well I told kids

when they play the game at the end of

the game they roll the dice if the dice

s number three then the third one that

was discovered gets to be the next seek

by this problem we have solved

uncertainty so until the end they don’t

know who is the next seeker and there is

no injustice because the dice decides

dice is not in just by construction so I

wanted to test my theory I you know what

theory is not a theory if it’s not

testable it might be some kind of a

hypothesis but unless you test it then

you prove that you were right it’s

really not a tear it is in the best case

hypothesis so I wanted to test this

hypothesis so what’s the goal of this

game in my view it would be to make kids

happier so I went and talked to lots of

kids and I asked kids to play again in a

certain way and then I taught them how

to modify the game properly and I

measured their happiness by the old set

of rules and by the new set of rules

that I gave them with the wrong of the

dice but now how do you measure

happiness of kids well you know

psychologists would probably do some

interviews they would do some kind of

questioning years with kids and that’s

fine I did that

but as an economist I wanted to have an

objective measure of happiness now how

do you objectively measure happiness

well I’m a father of four kids and what

I have noticed is that when my kid is

loud he’s usually happy so what I did is

I try to measure noise that the kids

produce while they’re actually playing

this game it turned out that controlling

for fights because you know they can be

noisier when they are actually fighting

so I kicked out all the measurements

when kids were fighting it turned out

that kids tend to be noisier meaning

happier in my world then they actually

play the rule according to the rule play

the game according to the rules that

make sense from the economic theory

perspective so what is the point of this

talk one would be there to be an

economist in spite of the fact that some

people won’t be able to distinguish

between lemons and peaches well I’m an

economist and I don’t want to be ashamed

of [Applause]

Please follow and like us: