
formative moment which happened to me in
my personal and professional life and it
took place on flight si 237 from
Johannesburg to London a few months
before I had made the momentous decision
to move permanently to England and that
day I’d said a sad farewell to my family
and close friends at the airport and got
on the flight a few hours into the
flight the engine suddenly started to
make a really terrible noise and I
realized that something was seriously
wrong with the plane I felt sick in the
pit of my stomach and kind of looked
around in my mind’s eye I had a kind of
image of burning in the engine kind of
premonition if you like and I tighten my
seatbelt and started to assume the brace
position at this point I should probably
mention whilst we mention really I guess
that I’m a psychologist who works with
anxious people and I’ve helped quite a
few people with the fear of flying in
this case I realised the problem wasn’t
one of the field flying we’d rather
problem with the engine I realized
though I was still feeling really
anxious so I thought to myself what can
I think about from the theories of
psychology that might help me to calm
down and what might be my last moments
so I went right back to the start to
Freud and Freudian theory in my anxious
state I couldn’t really remember a huge
deal of Freud in theory I must admit
apart from the eatable complex
this is Freud’s idea that men lust after
their mothers and resented their fathers
it was probably just offensiveness of my
part but I really couldn’t see how that
was going to help me in this situation
next Theory please I moved on to
cognitive therapy and it’s found a
professor Tim Beck being privileged to
meet professor Beck and one of the
cheeky kind of questions I had for him
at the time was to ask him really if you
could summarize an extensive lifetime’s
work into a few sentences of what his
main idea was and
the gist of what he told me was that the
key idea of cognitive therapy it’s not
so much what happens to you that’s
important but what you make of it all
very well and good until you’re an
aircraft at 40,000 feet that’s
plummeting to the earth next theory
please I realized I was starting to
obsess about the plane going down and
started to think about the theory of
intrusive thoughts and this started to
become really really helpful for me
intrusions are the thoughts of random
kind of thoughts that pop into our head
all the time a lot of them are have to
do once that we kind of notice and make
us anxious about things going terribly
wrong it might also be thoughts of
violence or sexually inappropriate
thoughts so you can see a few examples
on the slides there other examples that
are probably familiar to you is standing
on the tube platform and having a sudden
thought what if somebody pushed me in
front of the train or depending on your
personality type what if I pushed
someone in front of the train or
standing at a wedding and kind of having
the urge to shout out I object when they
ask if anyone does so these are kind of
intrusions and it used to be thought
that they were really the reserved of
people with OCD obsessive compulsive
disorder and that was what separated
people with OCD from people without and
this made psychologists quite
pessimistic about how treatable OCD was
because the assumption was that people
either had something wrong with their
brains that was causing them to have
these weird and wacky thoughts
alternatively they really wanted to act
on the thoughts either way people were
quite pessimistic then in 1978 one of my
former supervisors Pat mal de Silva and
his colleague professor Jack Rothman
published a groundbreaking study in the
study they asked a group of people to
answer whether they’d ever experienced
intrusive thoughts from a long list
including sexually inappropriate violent
catastrophic thoughts what they found
was revolutionary at the time that the
vast majority of the participants stated
that they had actually had these
thoughts in other words
anybody gets intrusive thoughts this
finding has since been replicated in
other studies so normally about 3/4 of
people would admit to get in distress in
weird inappropriate thoughts from time
to time from out of the blue and about
25% of people who will deny it
as psychologists tend to think that
these people as the graph shows maybe
so another kind of formative moment and
the theory of intrusive thoughts came
when professor portion kaskus who was
also lucky to be supervised by combine
these two ideas and so he took the work
of Rahman and silver he said that
intrusions are normal and we all get
them and he combined it with the theory
of Beck which is not what happens to you
that’s important but what you make of it
and what Paul argued is that intrusions
are normal and we all get them but where
they become problematic is depends on
what we make of the fact that we get in
them in order to illustrate this point
let me ask you to imagine for a second
think of somebody that you can think of
as really sexy
try and get an intrusive image of them
in your mind and my case I’m going to go
with Vladimir Putin shirtless dressed up
as a cosmonaut
whatever blows your hair back okay so if
you think about your intrusion not mine
would that be a positive negative or
neutral intrusion well as you guessed
it’s a trick question
it really depends on you and what you
make of the fact that you get in the
intrusion so the key really is to think
about intrusions as neutrons they’re
neither positively nor negatively
charged up until the point that we start
to attach a meaning to them let’s make
it a little bit harder now imagine that
the thought that you’re getting of the
really attractive sexy person the event
that you have in the fort at is your
best friend’s funeral and the person
that you’re having the thought about as
their partner now is the thought
positive negative or neutral again the
same principle applies it really comes
down to what you make of it so one
person might have that thought and think
this is terrible I’m an awful person for
having this thought I’m really
reprehensible another person might think
well I didn’t ask to have it and I’m not
going to act on it so it’s neither here
nor there and a third person might think
to themselves well my friends dead so
they’re not going to really mind and
their partners really fit so why not
so it’s always I guess the thoughts are
in the eye of the particular beholder so
at this point in time on the plane I
started to ask myself the most important
question you should ask about any
academic theory and probably one a lot
of you studying to ask yourselves now in
other words what is the relevance of
this theory for me or as the hashtag
says why should it get academic funding
is that a sigh of relief for me that the
start of the answer to this question is
to think about intrusions as spam so
while you’re sitting here today been
riveted by my talk you also been
bombarded with intrusions do I really
prefer chocolate to vanilla did someone
actually try to push me in front of the
train earlier today and a lot of time
the spam automatically just gets full –
the way to our spam folders we just
don’t tend to notice that at all
occasionally some of the spam
it’s way through out of the spam folder
and into our inboxes and that’s where it
can start to be really problematic so
what a lot of time most of us have been
really unhelpful tendency to think about
our thoughts has been reality so if I’m
sitting at home and I have a sudden
thought coming to my head nobody
actually likes me
I might treat that thought like reality
and then decide I’m not going to go out
and just withdraw and sit at home for
getting depressed this is where the idea
of a homunculus comes in a little person
who sits in our brain and can kind of
step back from our thoughts and valuate
them it’s on a good day your homunculus
might notice the thought maybe nobody
really likes me and think to yourself
well that’s just a thought it isn’t
necessarily true and I’m not going to
stop and get me going outside so that’s
how this process is called metacognition
and it seems like humans and primates
are probably the only people who have
this ability so how could I use
metacognition on the plane to be able to
help me to feel better I started to ask
myself what is it exactly that
psychologists have to offer to people
and anxiety provoking situations you
feel really really scared and vulnerable
if you sort of picture psychologists
going door to door carrying a briefcase
with their product inside what are they
trying to sell what’s the product inside
the briefcase and for me the answer I
came up with is that we sell less
threatening explanations for things
there lots of ways that we can do that
we can help people to focus on their
over estimations of the likelihood of
something bad happening or they’re under
estimations of the ability to cope but
often the simplest starting point is to
help people to realize that often most
of our thoughts are just spam they’re
just rubbish and if they just rubbish
the implication that follows from that
is that they don’t necessarily require
any kind of action anxiety thoughts
anxious intrusive thoughts generally try
to get us to do things and they have a
great urgency attached to them and often
the best thing we can do with them as
Blaise Pascal notes is just to ignore
them
completely so a psychologist want people
to have less threatening explanations of
their thoughts ways of thinking about
thoughts and we want to get people to
get better not acting in response to
their thoughts but the last thing we
really want people to do is to be more
country to be more stubborn and
resistant towards their thoughts so a
famous example of this was a
psychologist who took his class outside
and they’re sitting outside and a bee
flew past and one of the students
started flapping the arms around wildly
to fend off the bee and the psychologist
who was Tombaugh Kovac asked the student
to firstly stop flapping around because
it wasn’t helping them it was increasing
their sense of threat
the second thing walk evicted is he
asked the sight of the student to stick
out the arm and invite the bee to land
on it if it wanted to back in the plane
I slowly started to realize that assume
in the brace position probably wasn’t
very helpful for me at that point in
time so just as we want people to try to
be less physically reactive to their
thoughts we also wanted them to be less
internally reactive to them and there’s
two different ways that we can do this
the first way is to help people to
notice their thoughts more and to be a
little bit more in tune and accepting or
the fact that we get thoughts we’re
bombarded by the spam all the time and
we run into trouble once we start trying
to fight it off and repress them or try
not to have them at all lock him out it
started to occur to me that I’ve never
ever been afraid of flying before and
this just happened to be on the day when
I’ve made a really big decision that I
was quite ambivalent about when I
started to feel anxious it was much
easier for me to think is a problem with
the plane and it was to think I’m not
really not sure that I’ve made the right
decision and I’m going to really miss my
family and friends the second way that
we try to get people to react
differently to the internal intrusive
thoughts is to not engage in rumination
which is and worry over them intrusions
often about really terrifying things
most of which have never happened and
will
ever happen and so by definition they
can’t be solved and what people do when
they have an intrusive thought because
they can’t physically solve it they try
to do the next best thing which is to
think about it the problem is that the
thinking is actually warring and it’s
not helpful what’s the difference
between thinking and worrying thinking
you would be the equivalent of traveling
from here to Glasgow you might have a
few detours a few dead ends but you end
up somewhere different
warriors recursive you go round and
round and round and you feel anxious the
whole time warriors never never helpful
although we often try to convince
ourselves that it is the example of this
that always sticks in my mind is
somebody our scene for worried who came
in one week and I asked him how he was
and he said he’d had a terrible week
because he’d been warring loads about
whether to shave his dog in time for
summer and his fear was that if he
didn’t shave the dog it would overheat
in the summer heat which England of
course is known for I asked him at that
point a very unsuitable question which
is what kind of dog do you have and he
said oh no I don’t have one yet I’m just
thinking ahead to when I do have whining
how am I gonna react and for me that
really encapsulates just that just how
unhelpful worried really kind of is so
as you’ve guessed by now I guess there
was nothing wrong with the plane and it
landed safely if you asked later what
have I learned in the process whatever I
remembered firstly we all get intrusions
and a lot of these intrusions are just
really spam they try to get us to react
but actually the best thing we can often
do with them is not react at all in fact
what I’ve urged you to do is when you
have an anxiety induced an intrusive
thought to be oppositional to it so if
it tells you to freeze or to run away
from something you should move towards
it and that’s the thing that you’re
afraid of is something actually
dangerous like a bear in which case you
should probably freeze the other thing
to take from this is that intrusions try
to get us ruminating and worrying
thinking generally is a very overrated
process it makes a lot of people unhappy
and I don’t recommend it and definitely
not when it’s worried and you just go
round and round trying to solve problems
that don’t actually exist and psychology
isn’t rocket science certainly not the
way I practice it and these are really
very very simple ideas but they’re also
very easy to forget an anxiety provoking
situations I hope that the next time you
find yourselves in an anxiety provoking
situation some of these thoughts and
stories will stay with you and you’ll be
able to use some of these ideas thank
you very much [Applause]