Press "Enter" to skip to content

Are you constructive or caustic? | Aaron Bacue | TEDxKentState


just look at virtually any of our

Twitter feeds Facebook pages the

comments posted after news articles and

blog postings and even around many of

our dinner tables and one thing becomes

very very clear our discussions of

socially charged issues regularly

devolve into a win-lose battle

characterized by belligerence and

righteous indignation and the need to be

right at all costs in a society where

freedom of speech is fundamental to our

lived existence it seems as though many

of us have forgotten that our rights

also come with responsibilities and in

this case our responsibility is to

foster dialogue and collective

understanding rather than defensiveness

and aggression and we can do this by

building on the work of scientist and

philosopher Daniel Dennett we can create

a communication climate in which people

actually want to hear our criticism of

their ideas now Stephen Covey who wrote

the famous book the 7 Habits of Highly

Effective People is famous for having

said that most people do not listen with

the intent to understand we listen with

the intent to respond what’s interesting

about this is that Stephen Covey would

recommend that we actually focus on the

former at the expense of the latter but

reality suggests that we should really

focus on both the first step of this

process of offering criticism to people

requires us to restate their perspective

and in order to do that well basically

Daniel Dennett says that what we should

do is say it in such a way and say it so

perfectly

so objectively so clearly that the

person turns to us and says well I wish

I had said it that way in order to do

this we have to engage in active

non-judgmental informational listen

in other words we must listen with the

explicit goal of trying to understand

their intended meaning and this

necessitates that we suspend our

judgment and try to resist that rebuttal

tendency that Stephen Covey notes in his

famous quotation this is not an easy

thing to do this is why when I talk to

my students about this I encourage them

to wear a piece of jewelry such as this

ring and to touch that whenever they’re

trying to really focus their

concentration on listening because when

we do listen in this way we are then

able to verify that we understand this

person’s intended meaning not our

subjective and biased interpretation of

it when we engage in this act of

listening and then follow it with our

reiteration of what the person has said

this then indicates that we are

understanding what they’re saying and

that we are open to their ideas and this

openness makes people feel as though

their opinions are valued even if we

disagree with them this reduces

defensiveness and makes them more

interested in pursuing further

conversation with us it also suggests

that in turn they will also listen to us

with objectivity as Winston Churchill

astutely noted no.2 can in all things

agree all have some daring singularity

the singularity may prevent us from

agreeing on all things but it is seldom

that we can agree on nothing and so the

next step of our process is to

articulate those things that we agree we

agree with this person on although we

may disagree with for instance that the

cutting of funding for Arts and Social

Services is perhaps not the best option

we probably all can agree on the fact

that our taxes are way too high so

invariably even if we disagree on

something globally we can agree on

something fundamentally and we can bring

up those things and what we do when we

when we articulate this agreement is we

create what is called identification an

identification is this bond where we we

connect on similar experiences and

similar beliefs and values and there’s

strong evidence from the fields of

communication studies in psychology that

contrary to popular belief similarity

does not breed contempt in fact it’s

quite the opposite we like to listen to

people who are similar to us and we

particularly like to listen in people

with whom we agree so by starting from

agreement we frame our subsequent

discussion in terms of collaboration

rather than competition and when we

listen to understand the viewpoint of

someone with whom we disagree it’s it’s

very much like opening a book to their

perspective and as Confucius wrote you

cannot open a book without learning

something and it may seem daunting at

first but our next step in creating this

positive communication climate is to

reveal the lessons that we have learned

through this interaction with this

person doing so indicates that we’re

open to new ideas and and particularly

this person’s ideas and it also

communicates flexibility for example in

a recent discussion with a colleague

about gun regulations

I learned that fewer than 3% of gun

deaths in America are due to the use of

automatic weapons now I went to verify

the evidence of this and it turns out

he’s right so I learned this from

someone with whom I completely disagree

about guns and subsequently I have

changed my perspective on what we should

do in order to combat this problem again

we can always learn something from

someone even those with whom we

vehemently disagree as Daniel Dennett

contends it is only once we have fully

understood a

person’s perspective articulated it

fully and completely noted the things

that we agree on and revealed the

lessons that we learn from them that we

have earned the right to offer criticism

if our goal is to get our target to

truly listen to and ideally embrace our

perspective we have to communicate it in

a way that minimizes face threat

demonstrates empathy and conveys value

for them as a person one of the best

ways to achieve this is to resist the

use of what are called superiority

messages and instead use what are called

equality messages messages of

superiority are divisive because they

encourage us a UH us-versus-them

mentality as in the case of you don’t

know what you’re talking about

in contrast messages of equality

minimize status differences and

emphasize inclusiveness such as I never

thought of it that way but maybe there’s

another way to think about it

likewise it helps if we replace

evaluative messages with those that are

descriptive evaluative messages express

an opinion on the value or worth of

another person whereas descriptive

messages they provide information

without passing judgment so for example

we could replace an evaluative message

such as this immigration policy is the

worst ever proposed by a president with

a descriptive message such as there

might be some opportunity for

improvement in our president’s

immigration policy moreover it is

important to remember that our opinions

are exactly that their opinions and it

it will benefit all of us then if we use

provisional messages rather than

certainty messages provisional messages

offer ideas in a flexible manner that

suggests we’re open to discussing them

further

we’re certainty messages suggest that

there is absolutely no room for debate

consider the following messages taken

from a class discussion that happened

last week one person said dude you’re

totally wrong and someone else said well

what makes you believe that is it

possible that somehow the source of your

your evidence is is flawed or maybe

biased or maybe they haven’t considered

other alternatives now needless to say

you can probably figure out which one

created defensiveness so we just need to

consider better ways to say things so

that we aren’t creating this

defensiveness I also want to point out

that there’s that old saying that oh

well I’m gonna paraphrase it that

opinions are like anuses everybody has

one and they’re often full of feces okay

if we want others to listen to and

embrace our opinions we must back them

up with evidence to support them and

this evidence must come from

high-quality relatively objective

sources so the AP Reuters

The Economist c-span those all fit that

definition but things like the

Huffington Post Fox News Breitbart

Mother Jones the National Review Jezebel

they’re just too partisan for us to be

able to agree on them when we sit on

opposite sides of the proverbial fence

and unless we are established expert in

a field we need to make a concerted

effort to cite those sources anyone

who’s had a basic course in persuasion

and social influence or basic

communication knows that that is

fundamental to effective debate

so by framing our met our messages in

using these types of messages we can

create a communication climate that

nurtures respectful conversation rather

than hostile quarreling but I would be

remiss if I didn’t address the way in

which we deliver it there’s an

established in the field of

communication studies in inside

ecology we know that we’ve discovered

that when we use we messages instead of

I you messages we create a better

connection and people are more willing

to listen to what we have to say but we

have to also think about our tone of

voice and our facial expressions and the

gestures that we use because they can

either make or break our discussion it

is an established fact that nonverbal

communication or nonverbal our nonverbal

behavior communicates the most meaning

in our interactions and when non verbals

and verbals are in opposite directions

they contradict most people believe

those non verbals so if we deliver our

messages in the way that I just

described but we do this in a way that

has a tone of contempt or eye rolling or

gesticulating hands we’re sort of

defeating the purpose over the past

several decades the social sciences have

established that humans abide by what is

called a norm of reciprocity

it’s basically an unwritten rule that

that people should in kind return to

what another what they have received

from them so if we communicate our

critique in disrespectful face

threatening and aggressive ways no

wonder we have these spirals of

defensiveness but today we have explored

ways that we can discuss controversial

issues by fostering a communication

climate that makes others receptive to

that critique and each and every one of

us regardless of our individual beliefs

values and perspectives if each and

every one of us makes a concerted effort

to utilize these techniques we can

capitalize on that norm of reciprocity

and foster empathy and dialogue that

will move us toward collective

understanding and ultimately improve our

society in the words of Benjamin

Franklin any fool can criticize condemn

I hope I’ll stop acting so foolishly

thank you [Applause]

Please follow and like us: