Press "Enter" to skip to content

How labelling can be a double-edged sword | Alexander Carter | TEDxPearsonCollegeUWC


so I just like to say all of what I know

is based on the UK I cannot claim any

knowledge about mental health in Canada

or in any other country so a lot of what

I say will be very relevant so what is

autism autism is for those of you who

don’t know a mental condition present in

early development it is characterized by

great difficulty in language and

relating to other people as well as in

abstract concepts a to someone with

atypical autism will have many of the

same symptoms and behavioral problems

but it would have the symptoms will

develop later on and development my

sister my sister was a normal child up

until the age of 20 months but at 20

months it changed she developed epilepsy

suffering generalized seizures which are

caused by electrical impulses throughout

the entire brain she would lose

consciousness and then stiffen rigidly

going into what is known as a tonic

phase this meant she could was no longer

able to move to cry or to do anything at

all she never suffered the violent

jerkings but it would take two to three

hours to recover from each vet due to

the alarming frequency her care was

transferred to st. almond Street

Hospital which is Britain’s most

specialized hospital there were days

when she would have barely recovered

from fit when you’d have another and

then another and another caught in a

seemingly endless cycle and she but when

she turned four it stopped as properly

as it had started months of intermittent

electrical impulses must have had some

kind of long-term damage to her brain

this has never been acknowledged what

was noted though were delays to her

development

her sight and speeds Haring had

completely stopped during this period

and a hit Sutton and her son and a

speech had completely delayed even

speech therapists told her that she was

never going to speak luckily she did her

processing was completely damaged in

fact though she had average intelligence

she her reading and writing skills were

never surpassed that of an

eight-year-old and what of her emotional

development she developed she developed

complex behavior problems suffering

extreme anxiety one way this manifested

itself was through OCD or obsessive

compulsive disorder this is repetitive

behavior caused by unwanted thoughts and

feelings she was extremely terrified of

dirt to feel clean she’d have to had

have Oh hands wet at all times

this meant carrying large bottles of

water wherever we went her behavior was

inappropriate and embarrassing

she’d strip naked or wet herself in

large public places or even lash out and

hit people on the street just to feel

safe at the age of six we moved away

from London to a small town at the age

of seven my parents divorced which was

partly due to her situation we moved we

were in a Catholic community closely

knit ‘red but due to her behavior which

was often antisocial and hysterical

we were never we never integrated in we

were judged and shunned my parent my

mother was seen as a bad parent unable

to control her my sister was seen as

some kind of freak without a label to

explain or as an excuse for the school

and the community they had nothing to

blame the problems on we looked for help

everywhere she was even put on a gluten

and dairy free diet anything to help at

the age of eight she was referred to

cams with

is child and adolescent mental health

services they weren’t interested in our

epilepsy but they offered a range of

therapies including art talking

cognitive behavior and Family Therapy in

fact they can boast of thousands of

hours of footage of these therapies but

no one could help no one could put a

label on her the only two widely

diagnosed mental health problems in the

UK are autism which includes Asperger’s

and ADHD and both she was neither of

these and this was clearly stated on her

record she started off in mainstream

education but due to her processing and

learning difficulties she needed a lot

more help her teachers told her she’d

never be able to read or write she was

extremely bullied the her peers thought

that because there was no label there

was nothing wrong with her and she just

acted out because she was some sort of

as I said before freak because of this

despite it being a religious school at

one point her family at one point her

classmates planned to kill her by

burying her alive at this point she was

transferred to a special education

school the battle for funding began the

council didn’t want to fund her despite

her obvious need because there was no

label but months of sending letters

visiting the local MP my mother finally

managed to get support for her but then

at age 13 when we had to move to the

next step of Education which we had to

move counties the schools

told her she simply had to have a label

so after days of tests and assessments

the leading psychiatric leading

pediatric neurologists said that

diagnosed her with atypical autism this

was loose enough to gather support but

vague enough to leave treatment

there were so many signs and symptoms

that were similar to her but at the same

time there were so many boxes that were

left unopened that this label wasn’t

quite accurate with the label there came

a stigma

she was lumped into a category she often

couldn’t relate to she hated it

she was categorized as special at 16 the

anxieties became too much and she left

college she left school her fears social

fears were so great that she believed

all men including my father were

pedophiles

[Music]

she couldn’t be left alone her hands

were often bloody and she was extremely

depressed because of this it was decided

that medication was the best treatment

she was put on a series of

antidepressants and antipsychotics in

fact it took over a year to stabilize

her completely at this point she was put

in a specialist autistic school when 95%

of the people were of the students were

on medication she had no friends

she had never achieved basic maths or

English but despite this she took a

two-year course in art and design which

allowed her to go to college she started

at college the art College this year age

20

but the labeling that was so important

then now means nothing and the adults

health services are so over stretched

that unless you have a very unstable

personality disorder it’s almost

impossible to get funding this coupled

with the fact that only 32 percent of

autistic adults are in any kind of

employment means that 68 percent just

under 68% of autistic adults are

completely reliant on their families

they have no income from jobs or for the

so so when I wrote the first draft of

this speech I my sister had despite many

bad days been coping at school but in

the past few months she has left school

or stopped going to school she has been

told that she may be bipolar and she has

become increasingly unstable and

depressed withdrawing from all outside

contact when I was walking back with her

from the doctors she turned to me and

she crying she said I wish I had a label

instead of not knowing what treatment to

have instead of constant tests instead

of being lumped into a category she

didn’t belong but despite this we are

lucky that even though the label may not

have been accurate we managed to get one

which allowed her the funding to go to

fighting to achieve a label to get

support should be completely unnecessary

if the symptoms present validate a need

for help without constant help my sister

will never leave who may never live

independently would never have realized

her potential and gone to college

labeling doesn’t work so many people are

missed out and even when it does help

get through the necessaries systems and

necessary education a poor diagnosis can

be completely counterproductive for each

family it the story is completely

different a friend of mine who was

diagnosed with ADHD which is attention

deficit hyperactivity disorder and

Asperger’s was fully diagnosed at 10

though his parent one of them was a GP

managed to like who knew it beforehand

he had all the obvious traits and common

behaviors but he had very little anxiety

and living in London it meant he’d get

to get all the access to support and

finances needed his community due to the

obvious label

were very supportive of him and his

parents who had picked it up early on

were weren’t upset by the label or the

stigma that came with it and they worked

doubly hard to empower him to cope

despite this he struggled he struggled

that teachers knew him as autistic

before they knew his name a label brings

expectations of a certain behavior those

expectations can often lead to provoke

that same behavior it also effectively

pushes back somebody’s goals it may not

have been comparable to the way my

sister was judged but he too was seen

and still is seen to a certain extent as

a problem he’s seen as the labor way he

wears in fact we were best friends for a

long time I didn’t know he was different

they increasingly it has become more and

more apparent he struggled through his

teen years he struggled to fit in

struggling to cope socially it was both

even he may not have many friends now

and I

I even found it hard to cope or found it

hard to act around him I didn’t know to

treat him my own age or act like I used

to when I was younger it’s possible that

we have changed but increasingly I have

seen the label before I saw seeing the

friend I want to new labeling has given

him a barrier to hide behind a

limitation for his goals and an excuse

for his behavior is that all he expects

of himself all that is expected of by

others by others if more was known this

could change we could learn to support

more children better equipping them to

become adults and living the standard of

life that we have in 2013 the DMS a

Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of

Mental Health Bible decided as Burgess

was no longer considered a that decided

ass purchase was no longer considered a

disorder instead they widened slightly a

criteria for autism this caused so many

people to go on categorized and they no

longer got the support they needed it

also caused those people who did now

fall under autism to be treated as if

they were autistic which meant there was

a stigma surrounding them and it also

meant that they were getting a

completely different sort of treatment

treatment that in all probability wasn’t

right for them okay so I’ve spoken a lot

about autism but this isn’t a face an

issue just facing autism for example

schizophrenia so diverse other symptoms

that the validity of the diagnosis is

widely disputed people tend to associate

schizophrenia with violence and in fact

the word is commonly used as an insult a

schizo like right my grandfather was

diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia

when my mother was in primary school he

used this to justify his growing

alcoholism and his absence as a parent

my mother was sent off to boarding

school and then sent off in holidays to

family so that she never saw him if he

hadn’t of known if he hadn’t have been

diagnosed I mean who knows what would

have happened but would have meant that

he had no excuse that he would have held

himself responsible for his actions

it was also lucky that he managed to

keep the diagnosis a secret so that

children should not be given support due

to their label it should be given due to

their need and their parents need labels

should not be so defined it causes

stigmatization and categorization those

with labels they become defined by that

for those without they have no excuse

and are subjected to a lot of criticism

and judgment so what should you go away

remembering I mean is there anything

just by knowing about this stuff and

being aware of it and spreading the

knowledge you are helping for example

you may be walking down the street and

see a child acting out yes true it could

be a bad parent but at the same time it

could be some unknown unseen problem so

instead of looking away in shock and

disgust or looking away in shock and

disgust or crossing the street to avoid

smile and show support has an all

likelihood they are finding life a lot

harder than you and lastly if you told

someone is autistic don’t automatically

assume they’re like their TV

representation or like that kid across

the street because in all likelihood they’re not Thanks

Please follow and like us: